Straight Razor vs Safety Razor: Pros and Cons

Straight Razor vs Safety Razor: Pros and Cons

safety razor

For beginners, using a straight razor can seem daunting because the learning curve is steeper than with a safety razor. However, for some gentlemen, there is simply no substitute for the close shave that only a straight razor can provide. For these men, shaving using a cutthroat razor is a labor of love, and they learn to savor the routine. Time is one of the considerations when choosing to use a straight razor or a safety razor. Some men believe that newbies should start with a safety razor and work their way up to a straight razor, however, other gentlemen say it’s best to begin with a straight razor if that is your ultimate goal. Either way, you should be prepared to take things slowly and accept that it will take time to perfect your routine.

Pros and Cons

Using a safety razor can be more cost effective than using either a straight razor or the regular cartridge system razors commonly found at pharmacies and grocery stores. The costs associated with using a straight razor include not only the cost of the razor itself but also the hones, strops and stropping paste used to keep the razor sharp as well as the shaving brush and shaving soap or high-quality shaving cream necessary to procure the desired results from your shaving routine. The good news is that the expense drops once you have purchased all the necessary supplies since you will not need to replace them often, and a quality shaving soap like those from D.R. Harris & Co. will last throughout many shaves.

Which type of razor makes the most sense for a new wet shaver? As with most men’s grooming issues, it is an individual matter, but here is how the pros and cons stack up:

Straight razors

  • Con — High initial investment in blade, strops, hones and sharpening pastes and shaving brush
  • Con — Steep learning curve to master art of straight shaving
  • Con — High possibility of nicks, cuts and scratches — minimized as skill increases
  • Pro — Close and individualized shave and pride in the process

 

Safety razor

  • Pro — Modest initial investment in double edged razor, with minor continuing cost of replacement blades
  • Pro — Easy adjustment from cartridge to safety type blade
  • Neutral — Moderate possibility of nicks, cuts and scratches — minimize further as skill increases
  • Con — Fairly close shave with some limitations depending on shape and cant of the razor

Once the novice wet shaver becomes more expert, the choice will become clearer. Some men will diversify and use both types at different times. Rare is the man who abandons wet shaving once he has rediscovered the comfort and closeness of the shave possible with either the straight or the DE system.

Image credits: 365 Day 251 by Collin Harvey

3 Comments

  1. I’ve been using a straight (cutthroat) shaver for years. I started out with it and the learning curve is not as steep as one might think. You just have to start slow. Now, I use it almost every day (I still have a cartridge razor that I use when I’m in a rush or traveling). My only real advice is buy a new cutthroat. You may be tempted to use one handed down from your grandfather, but you should get a new one that has a perfect blade.

  2. I have been shaving with a DE for years, I finally made the plunge and bought a Straight from Fendrihan and a Merkur DE. Safety when I have time to relax and enjoy the ritual, and DE for when I am in a hurry.

    I can’t wait to see if a Straight really does give me a closer shave.

  3. I think if one were to purchase a slanted Bar safety razor. That would be the closet to a straight razor in the De world.
    Either way the safety razor is amazing and I am glad to Own one.

Comments are closed.